Salt + Light Media Menu
Salt + Light Media Home
Magnifying Glass
coverPhoto
Premium content

Asset title

Asset description

Deacon-structing: Married Priesthood Part 2

Deacon Pedro

Sunday, October 20, 2019

Msgr. Harry Entwistle (left), who recently retired as head of the Anglican Ordinariate in Australia, was a married Anglican priest with two children when he converted to Catholicism in 2012 (CNS photo/Paul Haring)
Last week I began a response to an email I received from Maureen Foster from Winnipeg. Maureen explained that she had just attended the ordination of a married man to the priesthood (a married United Church minister who had converted to Catholicism).
Maureen asked:
Can you explain how this came to be and what possible impact this will have for other Catholic married deacons from our diocese in the Roman Rite?
Do they all now have the option of requesting ordination to the priesthood? If not, why?
If yes, what impact could this have on the celibate non-married priesthood?
Last week I explained that the married priesthood has been part of our Catholic tradition since the time of the Apostles. But over time, celibacy became the norm.
Last week, the Church canonized John Henry Newman.  Newman was an Anglican priest who converted to Catholicism. While he was not married, there were other Anglican clergy who converted to Catholicism during his lifetime. I've heard from those who know Newman much better than I do, that he believed that celibacy was necessary for the priesthood, but he is known to have lamented on the fact that the Catholic Church didn't know what to do with these men. Clearly this is not a 20th century issue.
Newman always referred to a passage from St. Paul’s 1st letter to the Corinthians in explaining why he had never married. St. Paul wrote:
Now to the unmarried and the widows I say: It is good for them to stay unmarried, as I do. (1 Cor. 7:8)
In 1951 Pope Pius XII had granted special permission for a married Lutheran pastor to be ordained to the Catholic priesthood. Then, in his 1967 encyclical, On the Celibacy of the Priest, Pope Paul VI called for a study of married ministers of other churches who converted to Catholicism to continue to exercise ministry.
But it wasn’t until 1980 that Pope John Paul II allowed an exception for married Episcopal clergy who wanted to become Catholic priests. Since then, Vatican officials also have considered requests from members of other Christian denominations.
There are approximately 120 active Roman Catholic priests in the United States who are married (not sure how many in Canada or worldwide). Originally this practice only applied to men who had been Episcopal/Anglican clergy, but now they come from the Lutheran, Presbyterian, or Methodist churches. After they and their families entered into full communion with the Church, they would have had to petition Rome for permission to be ordained as Catholic priests. They would have had to go through priestly formation before ordination since the Catholic Church does not recognize ordination in other churches as valid.

As it stands right now, the celibate priesthood is not doctrine.

It is a discipline*. Because of this, it can be changed; it is "reformable". However, right now, this is the discipline: For men to be ordained to the priesthood in the Latin Rite of the Catholic Church, they need to be celibate. Married permanent deacons are ordained, but if a man who is single is ordained to the permanent diaconate, he cannot marry after his ordination. Again, a married man can be ordained, but an ordained man cannot get married. If the wife of a permanent deacon dies, he cannot re-marry. And, right now, a permanent deacon who is married cannot be ordained to the priesthood.
What the Church has been exploring these past years (and clearly since the mid 1990s) is the possibility of ordaining married men to the priesthood in areas where there are no priests. (Pope Francis first spoke about it in 2017.) This is why this topic has come up in the context of the Amazon Synod. It is a conversation that has also been had in relation to Canada’s north. However, even if this “dispensation” were to be granted, it is likely that it would be just that, a dispensation that is very specific to certain regions and certain circumstances. Those men may even be limited in their priestly ministry and perhaps even to their own dioceses.
I can add – and I think that this is what Newman referred to and why St. Paul wrote what he wrote – it is very difficult to be in full time, active priestly ministry and at the same time have a healthy marriage and family. I am not saying it’s not possible and I am not saying we shouldn’t have married priests, but there are very valid reasons why it’s more convenient to have un-married, celibate priests. (Just think what the Church would do with a divorced Catholic priest!)
After my response to Maureen, she wrote back:
I know we have a tradition of married priests, but for most, this is not a situation that they have experience with. My guess is most Roman Catholics would probably say married clergy is not allowed. Not many Roman Catholics have ever met a married priest. (I'm 46 years old and I've only ever heard of married priests in the Eastern Rite Church or met men and women who are married priests from Protestant denominations.)
I suppose this is true when it comes to deacons too. My children really don't know any permanent deacons. I experienced one ordination as a child. So I think we all need a refresher on the topic!
I hope this has been useful. I have written extensively on the Permanent Diaconate, so I won’t go into that at this point.
Maureen added:
I think the biggest confusion is why it would be allowed for a convert from a Protestant denomination and not allowed for our Catholic "born and raised" deacons.
I get the feeling some in the Catholic Church see it as unfair or jump ahead and think of it as a scary idea of change with regards to married priests.
Something you have said in your response below makes me think I may be on the right page with things here. As I have tried to read up on this a bit, I believe that this allowance has more to do with bringing together the Protestant and Catholic Churches back together again one day. Opening the door to welcome and unite those who may wish to come back to the Catholic Church - but already in a role of ministry, not wanting to give up a true calling by God.
Thank you, Maureen, for your question and your comments.
Perhaps, in closing, I can say this: We do have a tradition of married priesthood in the Catholic Church. This should not be a scary thing. These men are not automatically allowed to be priests. They still have to go through training and ordination. I think Maureen is right that it is a way to bridge the gap between denominations and the Catholic Church, but it's also a way to honour a call that someone may have had outside of the Church after they come into full Communion.
It's a great question and a great conversation.
Send me your comments.
--
*A reminder that discipline is NOT doctrine. Disciplines are universal laws of the Church. They may include particular laws of a diocese, liturgical norms, or Church practice. They require obedience by all Catholics. Those who reject them are considered to be in a state of "disobedience".

pedro
Every week, Deacon Pedro takes a particular topic apart, not so much to explore or explain the subject to its fullness, but rather to provide insights that will deepen our understanding of the subject. And don’t worry, at the end of the day he always puts the pieces back together. There are no limits to deaconstructing: Write to him and ask any questions about the faith or Church teaching: pedro@slmedia.org 


Related Articles:

Category: Highlight, Saint

Tag: Emmanuel Apostolatus, 聖多瑪斯, 黃錦文神父, St. Thomas Aquinas, 天行者國際使團, 林康政老師

教宗良十四世已抵達岡道爾夫堡放暑假14天

Monday, July 7, 2025

鹽與光

【鹽與光傳媒資訊】2025年7月6日(星期日)起,教宗將前往距離羅馬約25公里的岡道爾夫堡夏宮( Castel Gandolfo),展開為期14天的休假,直到7月20日。

教宗良十四世主日三鐘經講道:成為在福傳禾場上的工人

Sunday, July 6, 2025

鹽與光

【鹽與光傳媒資訊】2025年7月6日(主日),教宗良十四世在誦念三鐘經前向聚集在聖伯多祿廣場的信友們講道,反省了《路加福音》中所啟示的傳教召叫,強調教會本質上的傳教使命,勉勵信友們在日常生活中去成為堅定的見證人。他說:「教會與世界所需要的,並不是那些將信仰當作外在標籤、僅僅履行宗教義務的人。我們需要的是那些渴望在福傳禾場上工作的工人。」

教宗良十四世:我們為德州水災罹難者祈禱

Sunday, July 6, 2025

鹽與光

【鹽與光傳媒資訊】2025年7月6日(主日),教宗良十四世在誦念三鐘經後以英文發言時,他向在德州突發洪水中失去親人的所有人表達誠摯的哀悼。

敞開心扉說「亮」話:天主要我們有愛主愛人的心

Sunday, July 6, 2025

鹽與光

王新亮神父:「今天的福音對我們的生活有什麼啟示呢?我們的工作是重要的,但是我們不要忘記為了什麼而工作。如果我們的工作不是為了愛天主和愛身邊的人,那就沒有了意義。」

韓大輝總主教將於7月12日在多倫多主持講座

Friday, July 4, 2025

鹽與光

【鹽與光傳媒資訊】多倫多中華殉道聖人堂將於2025年7月12日(星期六)在多倫多中華殉道聖人堂舉行講座,主題為「慈母教會」,講者是駐馬耳他及利比亞宗座大使韓大輝總主教。講座內容包括:聖經和傳統的根據、教宗地位的反思、 共議同行的實踐。歡迎大家參與!

SUPPORT LABEL

Receive our newsletters
Stay Connected
Receive our newsletters
Stay Connected
Copyright © 2025 Salt and Light Catholic Media Foundation
Registered Charity # 88523 6000 RR0001
FR | CH