Salt + Light Media Menu
Salt + Light Media Home
Magnifying Glass
coverPhoto
Premium content

Asset title

Asset description

Euthanasia not dead yet

Deacon Pedro

Wednesday, October 30, 2013

20120210cnsbr08773
Two weeks ago there was a huge victory for opponents of euthanasia and assisted suicide in Canada in a case that determined that doctors must obtain consent before removing life-support from a patient.
The case was that of Hassan Rasouli who apparently was misdiagnosed as being in a persistent vegetative state since October 2010. According to his family –and apparently this is the case- even though, he relies on the use of a ventilator and a feeding tube, he is conscious and able to communicate.
The Supreme Court of Canada upheld the unanimous decision of the Ontario Court of Appeal that requires doctors to obtain consent from patients or substitute decision-makers before withdrawing life-sustaining treatment where such a decision is anticipated to result in the death of the patient.
And that’s where I think we need to make a huge clarification because a lot of people think that the Church teaches that we must prolong life no matter what. That’s not what the Church teaches; the Church merely teaches that we must not do anything to hasten death or in effect, kill the patient. This means that if the patient is dying, then we are called to make them as comfortable as possible and ease their pain but not necessarily keep them alive by extraordinary means. However, if the person is not dying, breathing on their own and their heart is beating, as was the case of Terri Schiavo, then withdrawing food and water is, in effect, murder. Terri Schiavo was not dying –she was not on a respirator– she was healthy. Food and water were administered through a feeding tube, but feeding a patient who cannot feed him or herself is not considered extraordinary care. Food and water are very much ordinary care.
But the case of Mr. Rasouli highlights another concern and that is that of consent. If Euthanasia and Assisted suicide were legalized, the fear is that doctors would be making decisions based on misdiagnosis or even on what’s more convenient or less expensive, rather than on what’s in the best interest of the patient. For some patients, their best interest is to let them die naturally and comfortably. Doing things to hasten their death or killing them is never in the patient’s best interest.
This is a very crucial time for Canadians. A week before the Rasouli court ruling, the British Columbia Court of Appeal upheld Canada’s laws prohibiting euthanasia and assisted suicide, in a 2 to 1 decision, by overturning the June 15, 2012, lower court decision of Justice Lynn Smith in the Carter case (which ruled that Canada’s assisted suicide law was discriminatory and, thus, unconstitutional).
These two decisions are encouraging for those who believe in the sanctity of human life. At the same time we should be very preoccupied by the ongoing debate over Quebec’s Bill 52 (An Act Respecting End-of-Life Care), which went into it's first vote yesterday and passed, 84 in favour and 26 against). I don't think we can ignore the fact that assisted suicide and euthanasia may be coming soon to a hospital near you. We must educate ourselves on these issues. We must reach out to our families, parishes, friends and co-workers to discuss this and share our Catholic perspective. A good place to begin is by looking at the document "Euthanasia is at our doors", recently published by the Catholic Organization for Life and Family and available on their website.
These are also topics that will be addressed at the next Euthansia Symposium, which will take place November 8-9, 2013 at the Renaissance Marriott hotel in downtown Toronto. Speakers include:
• Dr. Margaret Cottle (Canada) - Palliative care physician
• Margaret Dore (Washington State) - Choice is an Illusion
• Dr. Kevin Fitzpatrick (France) - EPC Europe
• Amy Hasbrouck (Canada) - Toujours Vivant-Not Dead Yet
• Dr. Will Johnston (Canada) - EPC - BC
• John Kelly (Massachusetts) - Second Thoughts 
• Derek Miedema (Canada) - Researcher
• Dr. David Richmond (New Zealand) - Euthanasia Debate 
• Henk Reitsma (Netherlands) - EPC International
• Tim Rosales (California) - Californians Against Assisted Suicide
• Paul Russell Australia - HOPE Australia 
• Dr. Peter Saunders (UK) - Care Not Killing Alliance
• Alex Schadenberg (Canada) - Euthanasia Prevention Coalition
• Nic Steenhout (Quebec Canada) - Vivre dans la Dignité
For more information visit the Euthansia Prevention Coalition.
You may also be interested in looking at some of our resources on this topic.
-
Photo credit: CNS photo/Gregory A. Shemitz, Long Island Catholic)


Related Articles:

Category: Highlight, Perspectives, 教會透視

Tag: arrested, 聖母朝聖地, 青年, 劉江東神父, 嘉模聖母, 嘉模聖母堂, 沈斌主教, 世界主教會議

教宗長時間不使用氧氣設備,繼續處理公務與會見聖座部會神長

Friday, April 11, 2025

鹽與光

正值教宗方濟各在梵蒂岡寓所養病之際,聖座新聞室在2025年4月11日提供有關他健康狀況的最新消息:病況穩定且略有好轉,如同肺部聽診器所呈現的情況。這幾天教宗會見了聖座副國務卿佩納總主教、加拉格爾總主教、魯索總主教,以及多位聖座部會首長。在教宗的委託下,桑德里樞機將主持聖枝主日禮儀。目前尚未公布聖週禮儀的指示。

耶穌聖容敬禮禱文及九日敬禮

Friday, April 11, 2025

鹽與光

在1840年代,主耶穌在法國圖爾,把對祂聖容的敬禮,啟示給一位年輕的聖衣會修女,即聖伯多祿的瑪利亞(Sr. Mary of St. Peter)。祂很想這個十分有效的敬禮傳遍世界各地,以賠補共產黨徒、無神主義者、詛咒天主者和褻瀆主日者對天主的凌辱。這些凌辱向天堂喊冤,比其他惡行更甚。

敞開心扉說「亮」話:在亞巴郎出現以前,我就有

Thursday, April 10, 2025

鹽與光

王新亮神父:「主內的兄弟姐妹們,不要讓我們生活在過去和未來的恐懼裡、絕望的虛假裡邊,而只關注當下,那樣我們就是和天主在一起。」

教宗要理講授:必須放下一切阻礙我們走向天主的負擔

Thursday, April 10, 2025

鹽與光

教宗方濟各在養病期間發表了他為4月9日週三公開接見活動準備的要理講授稿件。他敦促信眾放下一切重壓在自己心頭的負擔,好能體驗到上主無條件的愛。

英國國王查理斯三世伉儷在結婚週年紀念之際拜訪教宗方濟各

Thursday, April 10, 2025

鹽與光

教宗方濟各在聖瑪爾大之家私下接見了英國國王查理斯三世和王后卡米拉,對他們的結婚週年紀念表達由衷祝賀。

SUPPORT LABEL

Receive our newsletters
Stay Connected
Receive our newsletters
Stay Connected
Copyright © 2025 Salt and Light Catholic Media Foundation
Registered Charity # 88523 6000 RR0001
FR | CH